• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle






  • Your frustration is warranted. I consider mapping to be the major unsolved problem in the FOSS universe. It’s certain my one, and I have much more limited aims than you. I just want my personal POIs on a map, in colored categories, with access to that map on desktop and mobile, read and write. I’ve gone with the serverless route, just syncing the two devices, but the Nextcloud method is not so different.

    Well, it’s hard. Osmand is amazingly powerful, and apparently has the most advanced POI features of any Android app, but still there are catastrophic flaws. For example, in the GPX it marks up POI categories with its own bespoke GPX markup - totally invisible to desktop software (I had to write a Python script to add it to POIs created on desktop, just so that I can actually see their colors in Osmand). Next, syncing the GPX is made unnecessarily cumbersome by the fact that all the DB files and cached tiles are in the same file tree (I literally use an Android file sync tool to sync the GPX within Android to a place where it can be synced again with my desktop).

    What a mess. Pretty sure I haven’t overlooked anything for my simple use case of POIs-on-a-map. It just seems not many people want to do this. Or perhaps they tried and then gave up.

    Oh well. This rant is not much use to you, but please accept it as consolation.